Showing posts with label Commentary - Market. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Commentary - Market. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

Interesting Chart to Start the New Year

Best wishes for a happy and healthy new year to all!!!!

The new year often is a time to reflect on past years performance and future investments. During my reading over the holidays, I stumbled across an interesting chart at http://researchpuzzle.com/.  I encourage readers to look at the site and specifically the chart at  http://rp-pix.com/.

At the end of the year is is natural to look at the past year's performance. The chart referenced above looks at not one year's performance, but the past seven year's performance. Arguably, seven years is a reasonable approximation of a business cycle.  The chart shows the seven years total returns on the ten year US bond (TLT), investment grade bonds (lqd), and the S&P 500(SPY).   Interestingly,  these three very different investments have about the same seven year return.  However, they got there via very different paths. Stocks plunged and recovered, the 10 year surged and then pulled back, while investment grade bonds was a more consistent performer.

As with any bit of information, there are a lot of "conclusions" that can be drawn from one chart. Some things that crossed my mind when looking at this data include:
  •  I assume this is somewhat of an anomaly. I did not look at any other seven year periods, but if this is the norm, then there is no point to trying to make asset allocation decisions. More specifically it would seem surprising to me if in this low interest rate environment, bonds could match the performance of equities over the next 7 years.  That does not make me a bull on the stock market, but rather a bear on the bond market.
  •  Rebalancing would have worked better.  I did not do any math, but just from looking at the chart it is clear that buying the dips, selling the rips would improve performance.  Some might call that timing the market, I prefer to think of it as aggressive rebalancing. Perhaps we should all make a new years resolution to more diligently/aggressively rebalance our assets.
  • and...there is more than one way to get to the same place. Not shown on the graph, but any  traditional asset allocation across these different assets would also yield a similar return.  It also means that there might be other ways to match/beat the results/risks of a traditional portfolio allocation over a business cycle via the use of other instruments. One of those other instruments is options. In 2014,  CCI plans to continue to discuss option based strategies to provide alternative approaches to augment traditional asset allocations

Sunday, February 24, 2013

Do you have 54% in Alternative Investments?

This week's Review Section of Barron's quoting this study by Common Fund that said college endowment funds had an average of 54% of their assets allocated to alternative investments.   

Obviously, endowments have better access to a wide variety of alternative investments such as venture capital, private equity, commodities, etc than an individual investor.    However, my review of the press release describing this study shows over one third of these alternative investments are marketable alternative strategies such as absolute return, long/short, market neutral, etc.

Hmmm...........food for thought
  •  if the smartest, leading edge investors at endowments are using these strategies aggressively
  •  doesn't common sense indicate that an individual investor might want to consider understanding and deploying some of these strategies in their portfolios?

Sunday, February 10, 2013

Yet Another Forecast For Lower Returns For The Next Decade

This  Credit Suisse Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2013 by London Business School authors Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton came to my attention this week.  It can be found here.  It is not a "quick read", but does contain lots of information that can be good food for thought. 

One of its conclusions is that
  • Estimated annualized real returns for the next 20-30 years (i.e. the most important time frame for most of us).
    • global equities 3-4%
    • bonds 1%
  • Of course most financial services firms will quote, and generate investment plans around, something like the historical real returns since 1950
    • global equities  6.8%
    • bonds 3.7%
It seems there are more and more forecast coming out like this all the time. Perhaps these forecasters (and CCI) are guilty of just projecting recent results into the future.

Or.....perhaps the demographics, debt levels, artificially low interest rates, technological innovation,etc is driving a meaningful probability of this type of forecast for the next 20 years coming to fruition.  If there is some meaningful probability of this happening, CCI continues to believe that a meaningful portion of a portfolio needs to be geared towards out-performing in this type of environment even at the risk of missing out on upside performance if the market does meet or exceed the results since 1950.  This blog will continue to try to focus discussion on those type of investing ideas.

Sunday, January 27, 2013

Not a good week for rational market behavior

A few interesting things in the markets later this week
  • "Big time investors" Ackman and Ichan got in a “cat fight” on CNBC Friday afternoon. Some of it about Herbalife (HLF), and some of it about some ten year old deals which with they were both involved. However, most of it was about ego, perceptions, and emotion. While it can be entertaining to watch, what struck me was that these guys represent  the “smart money” that allegedly reacts rationally and unemotionally to market events to create an efficient rational market. To me the dialog is a great exhibit of one of the ways markets and their participants are not rationale.
  • Netflix (NFLX) reported a profit of $.13/share instead of an expected loss of $.13/share. That drove 2013 earnings estimates for the company for 2013 to somewhere around $1.00. The markets reaction to that was for Netflix stock to go up 70% in 2 days to $168. I'll let the reader figure out the p/e of a $168 stock with earnings of $1. (hint: 168/1 ..lol). Of course, this likely has nothing to do with valuations and rationale. Probably more to do with a huge amount of shorts being “squeezed”.
  • Apple (aapl) exceeded published earnings expectations. The market  responded by driving the stock price down some $50 (10%) in a day. The stock is trading below $450, down over $250 (35%) from its high a few months ago. Of course Apple will probably earn something like $45 in 2013. Once again I'll let the reader figure the p/e ( hint $450/45 =10)

This type of data points sure make me "glad"  that the most  investments are based on rationale, efficient markets and participants.

CCI will end this post here, but is pondering ways to capitalize on the Apple situation.  I'd be looking for the stock to stabilize and be range bound for awhile at some level just above here.  I'm considering buying the Jan 14 or Jan 15 $300 call. Then start to roll covered calls against this position.  For better/worse, this would create some leverage and hedging for the trade. This approach would be similar to the trades CCI did against CSCO last year as described here.  Stay tuned.

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Will there be a better level to buy in 2013?

The market was up again today, volatility very low, and greed seems to be trumping fear.


CCI stumbled across the data below.  CCI did not audit this info, but thanks to Avondale for their hard work.
                                                                      * * *

"Scanning data of the S&P 500 since 1957 produced only three other years that the index started the year positive and never closed negative on a YTD basis."  .........."Those years: 1958, 1964, 1976 and 2012.  The returns in these years were 43%, 16%, 23% and 16% respectively.   The full article is at

http://www.avondaleam.com/2013/01/years-that-s-500-never-went-negative.html


                                                                     * * *

The S&P (SPY) is now up about  4% ytd, and has never been below the Jan 1 opening.
Past performance is certainly not a guarantee of future performance, and "this time could be different", but....seems like the probability of the S&P having  back to back years where there is never a better buying point than Jan 1 is small.  Of course, interest rates have never been at "zero" for back to back years to before either.

Sunday, January 6, 2013

Bill Gross and CCI - Agree then Disagree

The holidays provided CCI a chance to catch up in some general reading of the financial press. One item readers might find worthy of reading in its entirety is Bill Gross (of Pimco) December Investment Insight letter. It can be found here

Overall the article is consistent with his and Pimco's “new normal” view of the world. More specifically, the article provides an excellent description of why deleveraging, globalization, technology, and demographics are macro level forces which could likely mean global GDP may only be 2% for quite awhile. Consequently he concludes that “Investors should expect future annualized bond returns of 3–4% at best and equity returns only a few percentage points higher. “ I agree with Mr. Gross's assessment of the future. If that forecast is accurate, it has dire consequences for investors, as it makes it increasingly unlikely that an individual investor (or even professional investors like pension funds) will ever be able to accumulate enough assets to fund a retirement.

The article then briefly discusses what an investor might do to react to this environment. Specifically, it lists some picks and pans for various asset classes. Generally speaking, this seem like good, traditional, investment advice. However, after very nicely articulating the rationale for a new investment landscape, it is disappointing that these actionable ideas are based only in the traditional components of asset allocation. Perhaps that is not too surprising since Mr. Gross and Pimco are primarily in the business of traditional portfolio management. However, it seems logical that if there is a new macro level environment reality, that investors should think about new ways to generate returns.

Some vehicles and techniques that might be considered by investors preparing for a new normal include:
  • Options – As Warren Buffet has said, speculating in derivatives can be “financial weapons of mass destruction”. Conversely, when used as hedges, options can provide portfolio protection against draw downs and generate income. This is especially true when selling options as opposed to buying them. The volume of options traded in the markets has steadily increased over the years. Someone is increasingly using this vehicle to reconfigure their portfolios. An individual investor not using options might be trying to compete without using all the tools available to them. Hence, individual investors should be determining how they want to utilize options in this new environment.
  • Margin/Leverage - Margin and leverage is a double edged sword that can help or hurt returns.
    Leverage can achieved be achieved via options strategies. Also, with low borrowing costs, perhaps now is one of the best times in history to consider carefully using small amounts of margin as a way to strive to increase return without increasing costs too much. Further with seemingly easier access to portfolio margin accounts an individual investor may have new opportunities to utilize these capabilities.
  • Market Neutral/Long-Short – Rule number one for many investors is don't lose money. This rule has always made sense because big draw downs in portfolios require even a bigger upside moves to get back to even. If overall returns from traditional portfolios are potentially muted in the future, it will even be harder to recover from big losses. That makes rule number one even more important, and that means investors may be well served to place more emphasis on striving to achieve more stable absolute returns. A portfolio configured to try to achieve more stable absolute returns will likely need to deploy some market neutral, long/short oriented strategies in their portfolio,

These techniques, like any other, are not guaranteed to produce the results an investor desires. They also bring with them their own set of risks. Investors deploying these techniques for the first time will have to take the time to learn these areas and find ways to mange the risks they bring. However, the risks of these approaches need to be compared to the risk of achieving traditional investment returns in the forecast of the future that Mr. Grosses suggests. If that forecast is accurate, there is not just a risk, but almost a guarantee, that just deploying traditional portfolio management techniques will not provide sufficient returns to meet long term goals. Hence it seems very risky to be 100% committed to only traditional portfolio theory. If there is a reasonable chance that Mr Gross's forecast is correct then it seem like some reasonable portion of a portfolio should be allocated to techniques that is designed to succeed in that type of environment. Perhaps now is the time individual investors need to learn how to invest in a new way for a new normal. CCI plans to put more focus on these techniques in 2013.

Sunday, September 23, 2012

CCI says "Right on" to BlogMaverick

From time-to-time, CCI likes to feature a "guest contributor"  and/or offer a general market commentary

I happened to read this posting on Mark Cuban's Blog that struck a chord with me. http://blogmaverick.com/2012/09/21/what-business-is-wall-street-in-3/.      Sometimes I agree with Cuban's perspectives, sometimes not.   However, one thing I like about his pieces is he usually just does not opine about some issue, but seems to try to offer some actionable, non-political, suggestion to address the issue. 

This post talks about how wall street has become less about capital creation/allocation and more about using the system to make short-term profits.  That is not an overly unique claim or commentary.  I also agree with that sentiment.  However, Cuban goes on to offer an approach to addressing the issue aside from the tired, old, outdated, populist, cry for "more regulation".    I'd encourage you to read the whole post, but I think the paragraphs below summarize his proposal well.  Agree with them or not....but to me at least I'm glad to see someone actually trying to propose a solution to an issue.

PS: Full disclosure: I am not a Mavs fan.....GO BULLS


* * * From BlogMaverick  * * *


"My 2 cents is that it is important for this country to push Wall Street back to the business of creating capital for business.  Whether its through a use of taxes on trades(hit every trade on a stock held less than 1 hour with a 10c tax and all these problems go away), or changing the capital gains tax structure so that there is no capital gains tax on any shares of stock (private or public company) held for 1 year or more, and no tax on dividends paid to shareholders who have held stock in the company for more than 5 years.  However we need to do it, we need to get the smart money on Wall Street back to thinking about ways to use their capital to help start and grow companies. That is what will create jobs. That is where we will find the next big thing that will accelerate the world economy.  It won’t come from traders trying to hack the financial system for a few pennies per trade.

And solutions won’t come from bureaucrats trying to prevent the traders from hacking the system. The only certainty when bureaucrats step in is that the law of unintended consequences will smack us all in the head and the trader/hackers will find new ways to exploit the system that makes them big money and even more money for the big institutions that develop products for the other institutions that are desperate to play the game."

Monday, August 6, 2012

Bill Gross and CCI agree.

While CCI was enjoying the summer last week, the financial blogosphere seemed to all have an opinion on this monthly newsletter from Pimco's Bill Gross.  You might want to read the newsletter for itself, but the main point I took away from the article is that Mr. Gross  is questioning weather the equity markets 6.6% real (after inflation) average return for the last 100 years can be counted on to continue in the next decade or two. This is very consistent with Pimco's often stated "new normal"  view of the market.

Many pundits and bloggers seem to think the market will generate at least average returns over the next decade, and feel Mr. Gross gives recent history too much credence, is just being bearish, "taking his book", etc.  Reinhart and Rogoff's book that studies eight centuries of data, concludes that debt driven slow downs do adversely impact market performance for a longer period of time. In general, CCI agrees with the idea that the next few decades may not  generate the same performance as the last 10 decades in the markets.  Who knows?

 However it seems that nearly every retail investor in the world is 100% invested into the concept that the next two decades will be like the average of the last ten decades.  They are 100% conceptually invested in something like a 60/40 equity/bond allocation.  Doesn't common sense seem to dictate that an investor should diverse some of their portfolio away from this belief/theory? It seems prudent that perhaps 80% of their portfolio is invested with the belief that the markets will have average performance of the next few decades. ...but maybe 20% or their portfolio should be investing assuming returns will have to be generated via other mechanisms (options, long/short, leverage, hard assets, etc).




Sunday, July 8, 2012

Back from vacation.... "shocking" developments

CCI has been silent for the past few weeks due to an extended vacation
(I needed to relieve the "stress" of blogging...lol).  

While vacationing, CCI did not pay too much attention to the detail of the markets, but did notice a few macro level developments such as:
- My understanding is Barclays seems to have admitted to somehow manipulated the LIBOR market.  What?  A Market Maker might  manipulate the market for their own profit??..Shocking
- JPM losses due to "the whale" traders,  rogue hedging tactics appear to have continued to grow well past the originally estimated $2b.  Hmm..do you think there would be any noise if a rogue trader had made a $2b profit while hedging?   or are we just suppose to be shocked that they actually can lose money?
- More evidence seems to have come to the forefront that CountryWide Mortgage (now BAC) was providing sweet, VIP mortgage deals to politicians in the early 2000s.  What?  You mean politicians might accept favors from the financial services industry in exchange for future considerations that might benefit  key actors in the  financial system.....shocking.
- A potentially disgruntled JPM employee claims that JPM sold more expensive, less effective products just because they were their own and there was more profit in selling those products.....doubly shocking.
- A month after the "efficient and straightforward" execution of the Facebook IPO the stock continues to trade well under the IPO price.  Shockingly.... more retail investor's than usual seemed to receive allocations.
- Central banks around the world continue to announce various agreements, statements, deals, plans, and policies to "protect" the "free" markets.  Using the words "protect" and "free" in the same sentence and no one seems to even think twice about what this really means for the state of the markets.....shocking
- I did not see any mention that any of the customer money that MF Global seems to have lost has been found...shocking

Less shocking is that retail customers  are still being "sold" the same old strategies, asset allocations and products despite that this does not appear to be your grandfather's market.  Common sense still seems to indicate that retail investors might be better served by not blindly following the advice of an industry with a record like the one outlined above. CCI will resume trying  to play a very small part in providing others investment thoughts when starting more specific market postings this week.

Thursday, March 15, 2012

What is worse than a Muppet?

The link to the op ed below received a fair amount of  recent commentary.  It was penned by a Goldman Sachs director as  part of his resignation process.  First it is important to note that this is just the opinion of one, possibly disgruntled, person.  Hence, it may not be entirely accurate. However, he seems to feel that at times...GS puts its own interests instead of its clients.  CCI was so "shocked and dismayed" by this possible revelation, that I decided to use this post to add my own general commentary to this "news".


http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/14/opinion/why-i-am-leaving-goldman-sachs.html?_r=1&pagewanted=2

One of the quotes from the op ed that attracted the most public attention was the author's claim that "Over the last 12 months I have seen five different managing directors refer to their own clients as “muppets,”".    In full disclosure CCI is not a client of GS.  I doubt many of those reading this blog are as well.  Their clients are more likely hedge funds, asset managers, sovereign wealth funds, extremely wealthy individuals, etc.  Not usually the type of investors I think of as being easily controlled by pulling their strings, of somewhat limited intelligence, or any other characteristic of a muppet.

 It got me to thinking.... If GS might think these sophisticated investors  are "muppets"...I wonder what they the financial services industry thinks of  members of the investor class?   Probably something even more easily manipulated, gullible, dimwitted, etc.     Who knows, but this just re-enforces my belief that the individual investor might be better off thinking for themselves and/or banding together with others in the peer group to get a more independent and useful perspective on their investment strategy.

Monday, January 2, 2012

2011 Report and 2012 Plans

2011 was the inaugural year for CCI. I want to thank all of you have taken the time to read the blog this year. I hope it has provided some insight for you, and look forward to your continued support in 2012. This post provides an overview of 2011 results and insight into plans for 2012.

2011 Review
CCI had two initial goals in 2011.
  • CCI's first goal was to see if I had the time and energy to keep this active/current for the full year, and if anyone would read it. I feel I was able to accomplish this objective.
  • The second objective was the basic goal of any trading log, to clearly document why an investment is  made, track performance, and become a better investor. Making the effort to documenting trade rationale seems helpful. Frankly, I really did not entire the year with any infrastructure in place to track performance. However, based on my cobbled together, unaudited, approximate review of 2011 posts the performance has been good. Specifically:

    • All domestic stock and options activities had just over a 5% gain. The S&P500 had a 2% gain (all from dividends). Hence, it seems CCI performed 2.5 times better than the market.!!! Of course, past performance is no indication of future results. However, this type of performance is consistent with the objective of the type of investing discussed in the blog. My expectations would be to under perform in big up markets, lose less in down markets, and out perform in sideways markets. Over the long-term, I think that will provide a better, more stable return.
    • The two international portfolio's both lost about 11.5%. It is a little more challenging to determine the right benchmark for these portfolios. My understanding is emerging market were down about 16% and developed markets down about 11% in 2012. Blending those two numbers based on the asset allocation that was used in these portfolios results in benchmark down 12.5%. I guess 11.5% is over-performance, but I would have hoped to lose less than that amount in a down market. CCI will be re-examining the approach in this area in 2012.

What's new for 2012

In the inaugural year, CC posted about a variety of stocks and options that I found of interest. The big change planned for CCI in 2012 is more focus. Specifically, in 2012 CCI plans to focus on six specific groups of stocks or portfolios. The stocks in each portfolio will be in a similar industry and/or share a similar set of characteristics. Within each portfolio CCI intends to use a wide variety of techniques beyond just being long equities. This includes the heavy use of options, some shorting, and a minor amount of leverage. Yes, these can be considered hedge fund type tactics. To many that may seem aggressive. However, it can also be viewed as the common sense way to invest in markets today.

This increased focus is intended to

  • Make it easier for readers to understand how specific post “fit together”
  • Differentiate CCI from many other “stock pick of the day” internet sites
  • Make it easier to track and understand performance

The six stock groupings are
  • Global Country Basket (GCB) - An alternate blend of non US ETFs
  • Options for Income (O4I) - Generating income via selling options 
  • Behind the Clouds (BTC) - Technology Sector, hedge fund
  • Utility Dividend Capture (UDC) - Utility Sector, Income oriented
  • The Short Game (TSG) - Shorting market indexes
  • Sweet Swing Trades (SST) - Traditional opportunistic swing trades



To support this focused effort, there will be some technology changes.
First, the groupings on the left side of the blog will be migrating to these six topic areas. It may take some time to evolve to this architecture, so the community's patience during the process is appreciated.

Second, CCI is also announcing the pilot release of a web site! It can be found at

This web site is intended to provide a platform to better contain common sense thoughts and theories about investing, better keep track of trades over a long period of time, and allow for future expansion of the concept of self directed investors managing and sharing portfolios in their areas of expertise.

Please note: this web site is a work in progress and will probably remain that way for much of 2012
For starters, CCI's IT staff (i.e. me) is still learning how to produce a web site and CCI is too cheap to outsource web-site development (for now). In 2012, the focus will be on adding content, and in future years potentially accessing better web development skills to improve the form of the site.
Secondly the web site is intended to grow over time, so for now several initial pages are listed as “under construction”. Throughout the year, CCI will be considering if/how this web site may need to grow, with the intent of formalizing it better in 2013.


Thanks again for your support in 2011 and best wishes for a happy, healthy and prosperous 2012.


CCI

Tuesday, December 13, 2011

2012 Sector Plan

The end of the year often provides the catalyst for investors to  adjust their portfolio via tax loss harvesting and general rebalancing. While performing these activities, one key consideration that drives  the performance of an equity portfolio of  is sector allocation.   A great  illustration of this point can be found at S&P's spdr website which states "Sector returns can vary widely – over the last 10+ years the average difference between the best performing and worst performing sectors has been more than 40% per year."

Clearly this gives a good indication of  how important it is for an investor to consider sector allocation. 
In that regard, CCI spent some time thinking about sector allocation for 2012 and documented those thought in the following more general opinion article
http://seekingalpha.com/article/313449-sector-weightings-what-is-the-right-benchmark-for-you

Thursday, October 6, 2011

"When the facts change, I change my mind. What do you do?"

Bespoke Investment Group provides a large amount of interesting, thought provoking market data.  On Wednesday 10/5 they had a post about recent market volatility.  You can read their whole post and better see their conclusion graphically at their website here . However, the key bit of info CCI found interesting was the following:

"Up 8.31%. Down 7.34%.  Up 5.34%.  Down 5.68%.  Up 7.38%.  Down 8.70%.  Up 7.34%.  Down 10.14%.  Up 6.65%. Those are the swings the S&P 500 has seen over the last thirty trading days."

That nets to a little over a 1% loss. Of course that was published before Thursday's 1.8% gain in the market. WOW. That is an exciting way to achieve .........nothing. 

I think this type of data should make an investor question their theory on equity investing.  Modern (circa 1952) portfolio  theory is based on many assumptions including that equity performance will be something like an annualized 8% gain with a standard deviation of 15.  I wonder what the SD for this zero return of the last 30 days might be? Perhaps this volatility is just unique past 30 days.  However, I'd guess ( not audited) that over the past 12 years the S&P has had something like an average return of zero with a standard deviation of 20.  So perhaps this is not really that unusual any more.

So why do so many investors blindly believe the advice from the financial services industry that says:  traditional passive portfolio theory is "good" and more active trading is "bad
".  

Paraphrasing the famous quote from the title of this post:

When the underlying assumptions change this dramatically,  I change my approach to investing. 
What do you do?


Sunday, July 31, 2011

A Year after Dodd/Frank, What has changed?

Last weeks anniversary of the Dodd/Frank bill and this weeks "show" from DC  caused me to take a step back and think more generally about the state of the financial markets since the last "crisis". (maybe a glass of wine was involved too). I found some interesting facts about the current global financial system/markets and put them in a general article below.  
 
The reader can draw their own conclusions. However,  IMO it seems that not too much has changed, and the markets are still "not your father's market" and may never be.  This leads me to conclude that investors need to be open minded to non-traditional strategies for non-traditional market conditions. 

So this weeks non-traditional post for informational reading can be found at
http://seekingalpha.com/article/283026-questions-to-ask-on-the-one-year-anniversary-of-dodd-frank

Thursday, May 19, 2011

Now that is what I call an efficient market!

I could only muster a general commentary today because I'm too busy counting my profits from flipping Linked-In shares.

Just kidding. After all, CCI is not exactly a "best client" of Wall Street firms that can "efficiently" profit from the arbitrary setting of a price at $45 and then watching it sell for $80 ...or was that $122...or was that $94. (today's trading range)

A few data points from today (unaudited)

  • Linked in's market value of $8b would put it near the middle of the S&P 500 market cap. I guess a web-site, eyeballs and a $161m in revenue is worth a lot more than you might think.

  • My understanding is 7.8m shares were sold in the IPO. Today's trading volume 30.1m shares. If that is right, on average a share changed hands 4 times today. Not exactly buy and hold!

  • 5th largest IPO in history (not sure how that is measured)

  • FYI, I tried to short this when it was over $100, but could not. I'm not exactly sure why. I think there are restriction on shorting IPOs until the initial trades clear/stabilize or perhaps there were technically no shares available to borrow to be able to short. All I know is I am really, really glad those naked shorting rules and financial regulation legislation are protecting me from market manipulation!


One last deep thought...... if Linked-In is so valuable by simply providing a network of professionals, maybe Common Sense says that a network of investors sharing their main street investment knowledge can be more valuable than the advice of financial services firms who orchestrate this type of ridiculous market activity.


Thursday, April 14, 2011

Findings about Social Media/Crowdsourcing for Investment Info

A little different theme to today's post. This was triggered by the article below.

http://seekingalpha.com/article/263429-seeking-alpha-as-a-predictor-of-stock-movements-and-earnings-surprises

In summary, this article highlights an academic study that shows sentiment on Seeking Alpha is a better predictor of stock market performance than traditional outlets. I've also seen some recent press summarizing analysis of how sentiment on Twitter is a good market indicator.

Obviously, Seeking Alpha (and CCI) are promoting this material because it supports our point of view that the mass intelligence of the investor class could actually be more objective and provide better results than traditional sources of investment advice. After all "crowdsourcing" of information for product reviews, recommendations for service providers, and reviews of movies/restaurants/travel are increasingly the source of information used by many. Shouldn't this main street level information be just as valuable for investments?

This article can/should be considered as "just" an academic study. Of course efficient market theory is also "just" academic theory. "Coincidentally" it happens to support Wall Street's objectives .....wonder why it gets more press? ...hmmm

Lastly, the research behind this article was done by individuals at the Krannert School of Management at Purdue ....where my daughter matriculates.......so "of course" it must be "right"

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Commentary - Nov 10 - Time to Sell Before the News

Since the spring of 2009 the overriding theme for this investor has been 12 by 11. That is S&P 1200 by 2011. The basis for this belief has been that the S&P 500 would bounce back to $80 in earnings in 2010 or 2011 and with a low risk free rate of return those earnings would at some point get a 15 multiple for a 1200 target. It was surprising to me that $80 in earnings seemed to be accepted fairly quickly by the "experts" this year and that the S&P 500 reached the 1200 mark so early in 2010. However, that was the right level to sell this spring and it seems to be the level to lighten up again right now

In fact, instead of stubbornly waiting for the S&P 500 to hit 1200 it seems like it is time to lighten up on equities right now. The recent run-up seems to have been propelled by the "rumors" of QE2, Republican victories, and solid q3 earnings. It is very likely that by the end of next week all the "rumors" will be "news". Players in the market may likely look at that news and disappointingly realize that QE2 is mostly pushing on a rope, Washington is still mostly dysfunctional, and earnings catalysts have passed. The news cycle may switch back to anemic economic growth numbers, structural unemployment, demoralizing news from a bi-partisan deficit commission, talked down 2011 corporate estimates, etc. Hence this investor is selling on/before the actual qe2 and election news hits.


With the threat of higher interest rates at some point making a bond "bubble" a possibility, the proceeds from sales will sit in boring,non-productive cash for the short-term. If my forecast is good and the market pulls back there will be a chance to put the money back to work at a better level in a month or two.